Joint Representation

Joint Representation

This post will answer some frequently asked questions on the legal concept of joint representation: what it means when one lawyer represents two or more people charged in the same case, how the jury is told to treat those defendants, why the ethics rules and the courts are so cautious about it, and what to think about if you and someone else have been charged together.

At a Glance: Joint Representation
Separate
each defendant gets separate consideration of the evidence, even with one shared lawyer
Personal
guilt beyond a reasonable doubt is decided for each defendant individually
Rarely advised
the conflict risk is so grave that a lawyer ordinarily should decline more than one codefendant
On the record
the judge must make sure each defendant understands the risks of sharing a lawyer
The law: District Court Model Jury Instruction 2.340; Mass. R. Prof. C. 1.7; Mass. R. Crim. P. 9

What Is Joint Representation?

Joint representation means the same attorney is representing several defendants. It usually comes up when two or more people are charged out of the same incident, such as friends arrested after the same fight, family members charged after the same search, or co-workers accused in the same scheme. Sharing one lawyer can seem simpler and less expensive, especially when everyone says they have the same story. But the law treats each defendant as a separate person with a separate case, and that has real consequences.

How the Jury Is Told to Treat Jointly Represented Defendants

When co-defendants share a lawyer at trial, Massachusetts District Court judges can give the jury Model Jury Instruction 2.340, Joint Representation. It tells jurors that several defendants are being represented by the same attorney, and then makes two points:

This does NOT mean that jurors are to regard them as if they are one person. Each of these defendants may receive separate consideration of the evidence.

The question of whether or not guilt has been proven beyond a reasonable doubt is personal to each defendant and decided individually. It is completely irrelevant how many lawyers there are in the case.

In practice, this means the jury has to sort the evidence defendant by defendant. Proof that one person did something is not proof that the other did. A jury can convict one defendant and acquit another, and it must do so if the evidence against one falls short. If evidence comes in against only one defendant, or is struck from the record, the judge can tell the jury how it may and may not be used. See our article on stricken evidence.

Is There a Conflict of Interest With Joint Representation?

Often, yes, or at least a serious risk of one. In most cases a lawyer typically declines to act for more than one codefendant. The Massachusetts Rules of Professional Conduct say so directly. Comment 23 to Rule 1.7 states that “[t]he potential for conflict of interest in representing multiple defendants in a criminal case is so grave that ordinarily a lawyer should decline to represent more than one codefendant, or more than one person under investigation by law enforcement authorities for the same transaction or series of transactions, including any grand jury proceeding.”

Rule 1.7(a) bars a lawyer from representing a client when there is a “concurrent conflict of interest,” which includes a “significant risk” that the lawyer’s representation of one client will be “materially limited” by the lawyer’s responsibilities to another client. Co-defendants can drift into that territory quickly. The Supreme Judicial Court has recognized that joint representation “may be plagued by conflicts of interest at various stages of trial: at plea bargaining, in selecting defenses for individual defendants, in deciding whether to call one of the defendants as a witness, in closing argument, and in sentencing.” Commonwealth v. Davis, 376 Mass. 777, 784 (1978).

Here is how that can play out:

  • Plea offers. The prosecutor may offer one defendant a better deal in exchange for testimony against the other. One lawyer cannot push one client to take that deal while protecting the client it would hurt. See Plea Deals and our article on proffer agreements and cooperating witnesses.
  • Defenses. The best defense for one person may be that the other person did it, or that the other person was the one in control. A shared lawyer cannot make that argument.
  • Testifying. One defendant may want to testify and the other may not. A shared lawyer may have to cross-examine one client to help the other.
  • Closing and sentencing. A lawyer arguing that one client played a smaller role is, in effect, arguing that the other played a bigger one.
  • Confidences. Comment 31 to Rule 1.7 explains that a lawyer in a common representation should tell each client at the outset that confidential information will be shared, and that the lawyer will have to withdraw if one client wants something material kept from the other. Comment 30 adds that, between commonly represented clients, the attorney-client privilege generally does not attach.

The Supreme Judicial Court has also noted a practical problem: appellate review is often unsatisfactory in these cases “because trial records are inherently incapable of registering forgone arguments and lost defenses.” Davis, 376 Mass. at 784. In other words, the harm from a conflict is often invisible afterward, which is why the courts try to prevent it up front.

When Is Joint Representation Allowed?

However, there are certain circumstances in which common representation of persons having similar interests is proper. Under Rule 1.7(b), a lawyer may go forward despite a conflict only if the lawyer reasonably believes he or she can provide competent and diligent representation to each client, the representation is not prohibited by law, and each affected client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing.

The notes to Instruction 2.340 say that the instruction “is not offered to encourage joint representation of multiple defendants, but to acknowledge that it sometimes occurs in the District Court for minor offenses, where counsel has investigated and found no potential conflict of interest.” Even then, if a conflict develops later, Comment 29 to Rule 1.7 warns that the lawyer will ordinarily be forced to withdraw from representing all of the clients. That can mean new lawyers, delay, and added cost in the middle of a case.

The Judge’s Duty to Inquire

It is the duty of judges to assure themselves that no conflict of interest exists. Judges also have a responsibility to ensure that the defendant adequately understands the risks and potential dangers of this representation and that each acknowledges an understanding of this information.

That duty comes from Commonwealth v. Davis, where the Supreme Judicial Court held that the trial court has “an affirmative duty to assure that each defendant is adequately informed of the risks and potential dangers of joint representation and that each acknowledges an understanding of this information.” 376 Mass. at 784–785. The notes to Instruction 2.340 describe this as a duty to make “due inquiry of counsel and/or defendants” that no conflict exists, including a colloquy with the jointly represented defendants. In plain terms, expect the judge to ask each of you, on the record, whether you understand the risks of sharing a lawyer and still want to do it.

Waiving the Right to Conflict-Free Counsel

A defendant can choose to keep a shared lawyer after being told about the risks. That choice is often called a waiver of the right to conflict-free counsel, and it should be knowing and voluntary, made after a real explanation of what could go wrong.

A waiver does not always settle the question. In Wheat v. United States, 486 U.S. 153 (1988), the United States Supreme Court held that a trial court did not err in refusing to accept defendants’ waivers and refusing to let one lawyer represent co-defendants, because courts have an independent interest in making sure trials are fair and ethical. The presumption in favor of the lawyer you choose can be overcome by an actual conflict or by a serious potential for one.

For these reasons, separate counsel is usually the better course. Each defendant then has a lawyer whose only job is that defendant’s case: weighing that defendant’s plea options, choosing that defendant’s defense, and deciding whether that defendant should testify, without worrying about the effect on anyone else.

Joint Trials and Severance

Joint representation is different from a joint trial. Even when each defendant has a separate lawyer, defendants are often tried together. Under Mass. R. Crim. P. 9(b), two or more defendants may be charged in the same complaint or indictment if the charges arise out of the same criminal conduct or episode, or out of a connected course of conduct, scheme, plan, conspiracy, or joint enterprise.

If a joint trial is not in the best interests of justice, Rule 9(d) lets the judge grant a severance of defendants, meaning separate trials, or other relief. A defendant asking for a severance generally must file a written motion before trial, supported by an affidavit explaining the prejudice. A severance motion may be made later, up to the close of the evidence, only if it is based on a ground not previously known. Timing matters, so this is something to raise with your lawyer early, often around the pre-trial conference.

Co-Defendant Statements and the Bruton Problem

One of the most common reasons for a severance is a statement by a co-defendant. Suppose one defendant gave the police a statement that also blames the other, and the defendant who made it does not testify at trial. In Bruton v. United States, 391 U.S. 123 (1968), the United States Supreme Court held that admitting a non-testifying co-defendant’s confession that implicated the defendant at their joint trial violated the defendant’s right to cross-examination under the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment, even though the jury had been told to disregard the confession as to him. The Court found a substantial risk that jurors would look to the statement anyway.

The reporter’s notes to Rule 9 explain that Bruton does not require separate trials in every case. A statement may sometimes be admitted if references to the other defendant can be removed, or if the co-defendant who made it testifies and can be cross-examined. Whether that works depends on the exact words of the statement. If you are charged with someone who spoke to the police, your lawyer should get that statement early and decide whether to seek redaction or a separate trial. For more on police statements, see Police Interrogations in Massachusetts.

Statement problems are another reason one lawyer for two co-defendants is risky. A shared lawyer cannot attack a co-defendant’s statement as unreliable when that co-defendant is also the lawyer’s client.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my co-defendant and I use the same lawyer to save money?

It is sometimes allowed, but it is usually not advised. The lawyer must believe the conflict risk can be managed, each of you must give informed written consent, and the judge must make sure each of you understands the risks. If your interests split later, the lawyer will ordinarily have to withdraw from representing both of you.

Will the jury hold my co-defendant’s conduct against me?

It is not supposed to. Under Instruction 2.340, each defendant is entitled to separate consideration of the evidence, and guilt beyond a reasonable doubt is decided for each defendant individually.

Can I ask for a separate trial?

Yes. Under Rule 9(d), a defendant can move for relief from prejudicial joinder, including a severance. The motion generally must be in writing, filed before trial, and supported by an affidavit.

What if my co-defendant made a statement blaming me?

That raises a Bruton issue. Depending on the statement, the remedy may be redaction, a separate trial, or exclusion of the statement against you. Talk to your lawyer before trial so the issue is raised in time.

Talk to a Massachusetts Defense Lawyer About Your Case

If you and someone else have been charged in the same case, the decisions you make early, including who represents you, can shape everything that follows. If you or a loved one have a legal question or have been charged with a crime, contact the Law Office of William J. Barabino in Medford. Attorney Barabino represents clients in criminal defense matters throughout Greater Boston.

Call 781-393-5900 to learn more about your available defenses.

Related Articles

Disclaimer

This article is for general educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Massachusetts statutes, court rules, model jury instructions, and court decisions can change, and every case turns on its own facts. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. If you are facing a criminal charge, consult a licensed Massachusetts criminal defense attorney about your situation.