Gang affiliation can be a powerful piece of evidence. It can also be deeply unfair if misused. Massachusetts courts take this seriously. They set clear limits on how gang evidence can be used at trial. So, what rules protect the fairness of a trial when this kind of evidence is introduced?
Can Gang Affiliation Be Used to Prove Guilt?
No. The jury is clearly instructed not to rely on gang affiliation as a shortcut to finding someone guilty. Evidence that a person is, or might be, connected to a gang cannot be used to judge their character or assume they are likely to commit a crime. That kind of evidence does not prove the defendant acted violently or committed the offense. It’s not a stand-in for real proof.
When is Gang Affiliation Evidence Allowed?
Sometimes, courts may allow gang affiliation evidence, but only for specific reasons. These include:
- To show motive. For example, if the crime was committed as an act of gang retaliation.
- To prove joint venture. This means showing that several people acted together because they shared a gang connection.
Even when the evidence is allowed, the jury can only use it for these purposes. It cannot be used for anything else.
What if the Defendant Just Believed Someone Was in a Gang?
Sometimes, a person acts based on what they believe. The defendant may have thought someone else was in a gang. But that belief alone does not prove the other person actually was. It may be relevant to show what the defendant was thinking at the time. It cannot be used to prove anything about the other person.
What About Expert Testimony?
Sometimes, a prosecutor may call a gang expert to testify. Or the defense may call a gang expert to prove disprove that the person is in a gang or the suggested affiliation. This is someone with special training or experience who can explain signs of gang behavior or affiliation. But it’s up to the jury to decide how much weight to give that testimony, if the testimony is admitted at trial. The expert is just like any other witness.
Why Jurors Must be Especially Careful with Gang Evidence
Gang affiliation can have a strong effect on a jury. It can create fear, trigger bias, and lead to harmful stereotypes. That’s why Massachusetts courts urge caution. During jury selection, potential jurors are asked whether they can stay fair if gang ties are mentioned. Those who are chosen must swear to remain impartial through the trial. Judges also play a role in protecting fairness. They must decide if the evidence helps more than it harms. If it is allowed, the judge must explain exactly how it can be used—and how it cannot.
End result
Gang affiliation is not an excuse to bring in damaging background details. The law limits how this kind of evidence can be used. It must be clearly explained and narrowly focused.
IF YOU OR A LOVED ONE NEED CRIMINAL LAW ADVICE, CONTACT CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY WILLIAM J. BARABINO.
CALL 781-393-5900 TO LEARN MORE ABOUT YOUR AVAILABLE DEFENSES.
Related Articles:
