Attorney for Clerk Magistrate Hearings

Attorney for Clerk Magistrate Hearings

A clerk magistrate hearing, sometimes called a show-cause hearing, is a chance to be heard before a criminal complaint issues. Attorney Barabino represents people at these hearings in Massachusetts.

Attorney Barabino has a great deal of experience at clerk magistrate hearings, and many of his clients have left without a criminal complaint ever issuing.

If you have received a citation or a notice of a clerk magistrate hearing, contact the Medford, Massachusetts, law office of William Barabino at 781-393-5900 for a free and confidential consultation.

When a Hearing Is Available

Clerk magistrate hearings are not limited to driving cases. They are also held for non-driving charges. The way a person who has not been arrested obtains the hearing depends on the kind of case.

  • Non-driving misdemeanors: A person who was not arrested is generally entitled to a hearing as a matter of right under G.L. c. 218, § 35A, if there is no imminent threat of bodily injury, of the commission of a crime, or of flight from the commonwealth. The court sends notice of the hearing. There is no four-day filing requirement for these cases.
  • Driving citations: For a misdemeanor motor-vehicle or driving offense charged by citation, a person who was cited and not arrested is entitled to a hearing as a matter of right if a written request arrives at the court within four days of the date of the violation (G.L. c. 90C, § 3). That four-day requirement applies only to driving citations and is described below.
  • Felonies: A hearing is not a matter of right, but a person may still get one if the police seek it and the court sends notice of a clerk magistrate hearing. If a law-enforcement officer applies for a felony complaint and requests a hearing, and none of the three exceptions above applies, the magistrate must schedule one. On a private felony application, the magistrate may give a hearing, but is not required to.

The police may also file an application for a criminal complaint and ask that it be set for a clerk magistrate hearing. When a notice of a clerk magistrate hearing arrives, for any charge, contact an attorney right away and begin to prepare.

The Four-Day Process for Motor-Vehicle Citations

The four-day written request applies only to driving citations. It is the route by which a person cited, and not arrested, for a misdemeanor driving offense obtains a clerk magistrate hearing as a matter of right (G.L. c. 90C, § 3). It does not apply to non-driving charges; those hearings, when they are held, are scheduled on notice from the court, as described above.

How the four-day process works:

  • The person must request the hearing in writing.
  • That writing must arrive at the court within four days of the date of the violation.
  • The hearing is not held that day. A later date is scheduled, and notice comes by mail.
  • A timely request generally grants the hearing when the charge is a misdemeanor, there is no accompanying felony, and the person was cited and not arrested.
  • Missing the deadline waives the hearing, and a complaint can issue without one.

For a driving citation, the written request must reach the court within four days of the violation, or the right to a hearing is lost.

This route can apply to a range of motor-vehicle charges, including:

  • Negligent operation
  • Leaving the scene of property damage
  • Leaving the scene of personal injury
  • Operating under the influence, if the person was cited and not arrested

It does not apply as of right to:

  • Leaving the scene of a crash that resulted in death, which is a felony
  • An OUI in which the person was arrested
  • A subsequent or aggravated OUI charged as a felony

What Happens at the Hearing

It can take weeks to receive notice, and it can take months for the hearing to be scheduled, depending on the court.

The hearing is private. It is usually held in a small room, or in a courtroom closed to the public. At this stage no complaint has issued, and there is no reason the hearing should be public.

Who Is in the Room

The people usually present are:

  • The clerk magistrate, who decides whether there is probable cause and whether a complaint should issue
  • A police prosecutor (who may or may not be a lawyer)
  • The accused
  • The attorney, if the person has one
  • Any witnesses
  • A private complainant, if a private citizen applied for the complaint

A person does not have to have a lawyer, but it is always advisable. There is no appointed counsel at this stage.

The Standard Is Probable Cause

The police, or a private complainant, present the application, often by reading the police report. The standard is not proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the standard in a criminal trial. The standard is probable cause, a relatively low threshold: reasonably trustworthy information sufficient to warrant a prudent person in believing that a crime has been committed and that the accused committed it.

The standard at a clerk magistrate hearing is probable cause, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

Making the Case

The accused has the right to be heard in opposition, personally or through counsel, and to present evidence. You can ask to question the officer and present witnesses. Whether the officer or other witnesses are questioned is up to the magistrate.

Even if probable cause is established, the case need not go forward. The magistrate may decline to issue a complaint, keep the matter open, or continue it on conditions, such as counseling or classes. A person is not entitled to those options. If a complaint issues, the case then goes to the district attorney.

Even if probable cause is established, the clerk magistrate may still decline to issue a complaint.

Possible results include:

  • The magistrate finds no probable cause, and no complaint issues
  • The magistrate finds probable cause but declines to issue a complaint
  • The matter is kept open, or continued on conditions such as counseling or classes, and later closed without a complaint
  • A complaint issues, and the case goes to the district attorney

What You Can Bring

There is no limit to what a person can offer at a clerk magistrate hearing. One goal is to go in prepared to argue that, even if probable cause is established, the case should not go forward.

Persuading a police prosecutor, whose job is to prosecute crimes, and a clerk magistrate, who has a responsibility to administer justice, takes preparation. They handle a great many cases, and they have to do that work objectively and feel comfortable with the result. Part of that job, in the interest of justice, includes some flexibility. They are two human beings who understand that people make mistakes.

A request is most persuasive when it is:

  • Well prepared, with documents in hand
  • Presented with humility
  • Supported by a justification for what is being asked

Presented correctly, a complaint can be avoided even when there is probable cause.

There is no restriction on what can be brought. That can include:

  • A mental-health or alcohol evaluation, and follow-through that has already been completed
  • Letters or affidavits of support from friends, relatives, or people involved, including a potential victim
  • Restitution or insurance paid in full, with receipts
  • Online and in-person programs that have been completed and can be presented
  • Inpatient treatment, including for mental health, begun or completed before the hearing

The goal is to come in very well prepared.

Charges Resolved at Clerk Magistrate Hearings

Attorney Barabino has represented people at clerk magistrate hearings on a wide range of charges. These are among the types of charges on which no criminal complaint issued. This is not a guarantee of a particular result.

Motor Vehicle Charges

  • Failure to stop for police
  • Leaving the scene of personal injury
  • Leaving the scene of property damage
  • Negligent operation of a motor vehicle
  • Operating after suspension
  • Operating an uninsured motor vehicle
  • Operating an unregistered motor vehicle
  • Operating under the influence
  • Permitting an unlicensed operator
  • Racing a motor vehicle
  • Reckless operation of a motor vehicle
  • Unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle

Assault and Related Charges

  • Annoying and accosting
  • Assault
  • Assault and battery
  • Assault and battery on a police officer
  • Assault and battery on a pregnant person
  • Assault and battery with a dangerous weapon
  • Assault by means of a dangerous weapon
  • Domestic assault and battery
  • False bomb threat
  • Threats
  • Witness intimidation

Property and Theft Charges

  • Breaking and entering
  • Evading taxi fare
  • Larceny
  • Malicious destruction of property
  • Receiving stolen property
  • Shoplifting
  • Trespassing
  • Vandalism

Other Charges

  • Cheating and swindling under the Gaming Act
  • Conspiracy
  • Disorderly conduct
  • Disturbing a school assembly
  • Disturbing the peace
  • Impeding a gaming investigation
  • Improper storage of a firearm
  • Indecent exposure
  • Minor in possession of alcohol
  • Possession of a Class B substance
  • Possession of a forged or false license
  • Uttering a false prescription
  • Violation of a harassment prevention order or a restraining order

Additional clerk magistrate hearing results are on the Recent Cases page.

How Attorney Barabino Prepares

Was there any guarantee that these cases would be won? No. Attorney Barabino never gives one, and no lawyer can. Given the charge, there can be some level of predictability, but a weakness is going in expecting an easy win and then not winning because the case was not prepared.

  • He prepares every time, whatever the charge.
  • He prepares as if the magistrate hearing is the goal.
  • Once a complaint issues, the case goes to the district attorney, and that opportunity is lost.

The magistrate hearing is a chance to avoid a criminal complaint and a CORI entry.

There is no guarantee of a particular result, and no lawyer can give one.

Contact William Barabino at 781-393-5900

If you are facing a clerk magistrate hearing, contact criminal defense attorney William Barabino by calling his Medford, Massachusetts, law office at 781-393-5900. You may also complete his online contact form. Whatever your situation, we are ready to address it and to find what works best for you.