Attorney Barabino represents people on both sides of a Massachusetts restraining order: those who ask the court for one and those who have been served with one. This page covers the civil abuse prevention order, commonly called a restraining order or a 209A order (G.L. c. 209A), and the criminal charge that can follow if a person is accused of violating it.
A 209A order is issued by a Massachusetts court to protect a "family or household member": a spouse or former spouse, someone who lives or has lived with you, a relative, a person you share a child with, or someone in a substantive dating relationship. A separate law, G.L. c. 258E, allows harassment prevention orders against anyone. See Attorney Barabino's page on Harassment Prevention Orders.
If someone is seeking a restraining order against you, you may have only a few days to respond. Contact the Medford, Massachusetts, law office of William Barabino at 781-393-5900 for a free and confidential consultation.
How a 209A Restraining Order Is Issued
These cases move quickly. In 23 years, Attorney Barabino has handled them for both plaintiffs and defendants.
Emergency Orders When the Court Is Closed
When the courts are closed, the police can contact a judge who is on call. If the judge finds a substantial likelihood of immediate danger of abuse, the judge can issue an emergency order by phone. It lasts only until the end of the next court business day, when the person who asked for it must go to court to ask that it continue. Otherwise, a person can go to a courthouse during business hours, generally 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on weekdays.
Orders Without the Other Person, and the Ten-Day Hearing
A judge can issue a temporary order "ex parte," meaning without the other person present, if the person asking shows a substantial likelihood of immediate danger of abuse. At this stage the order is civil, but it is still a court order and has to be taken seriously. Because everyone has a right to due process, the other person must be given a chance to be heard no later than ten court business days later. Weekends and holidays do not count. If that person does not come, the temporary order simply continues.
At the hearing, the judge hears the evidence and testimony, and each side may cross-examine. The person asking for the order must prove abuse by a preponderance of the evidence. "Abuse" includes causing or attempting to cause physical harm, placing someone in fear of imminent serious physical harm, forcing sexual relations, and, since 2024, coercive control.
An order can be issued without the other person present, but that person is entitled to a hearing within ten court business days, where the judge hears the evidence and both sides can cross-examine.
Orders for Up to One Year, and Extensions
If the judge issues the order after the hearing, it lasts for a fixed period of up to one year, and the order states when it ends. Before then, the other person can ask the judge to extend it or enter a permanent order, and must again show it is still needed. Either side can also ask the court to change or end an order.
When a Restraining Order Is in Place
These cases are hard on families. For many people it is a first time in a courthouse. A person may be told, sometimes in the middle of winter, that they cannot go home, cannot contact their children or spouse, and cannot reach the other person through anyone else. Tensions are always high, and a contact that feels harmless can become a criminal charge.
What the Order Can Require
A judge can order no contact in any form, including calls, texts, email, social media, or through friends and relatives. A judge can also order a person to leave and stay away from a home, workplace, or school, even if the person's name is on the lease or deed, to avoid named children, and to surrender firearms. A 209A order is civil, not a criminal conviction, but it is entered in a statewide registry that courts and police can see, even after the order ends. These records generally cannot be expunged.
Getting Belongings With Police Present
A judge can allow a person to return to the home for clothing, medication, and other immediate belongings, but only with police present and at a time the other person agrees to. A person has to ask the judge for this, and the judge decides. Going back on your own can be a violation.
Deciding Whether to Testify at the Civil Hearing
As a criminal defense lawyer, Attorney Barabino looks at these hearings differently from a lawyer who handles only civil cases. Testimony at a civil hearing is under oath, and a prosecutor can obtain it.
The Risk of Self-Incrimination
The key decision is whether the client should testify at all. Will the client say something, on direct or on cross-examination, that admits a crime? The answer usually takes long, detailed meetings, generally a couple of them. Staying silent has a cost too: in a civil case the judge may consider a person's silence, though it cannot alone support an order. All of this has to happen in about nine or ten days, so the pace is quick and detailed. People who go in alone or unprepared can make a serious mistake without realizing it.
The biggest risk at the civil hearing is testifying to defend the order and, in doing so, giving sworn evidence of a crime that can be used to prosecute you.
When Restraining Orders Are Used Against You
As an experienced criminal defense attorney, Attorney Barabino understands that restraining orders may be used for unintended purposes, such as gaining leverage in child custody, divorce, and related probate matters, or as punishment by a former partner. Whatever the reason an order was entered, it is up to you to respond at the hearing with the evidence and witnesses you need. An experienced criminal defense attorney makes a real difference there.
If You Are Accused of Violating a Restraining Order
Violating a restraining order is a crime. Every 209A order states, "Violation of this order is a criminal offense." Police are required to arrest a person they see, or have probable cause to believe, violated the order, and they do not need a warrant.
How Easily It Can Happen
Many people accused of violating a 209A order did not realize their actions were prohibited. Accusations often come from events like these:
- Mailing a letter to the person
- Responding to a voice mail or text from an ex
- Contacting the person through a neighbor, relative, or friend
- Driving past the person's house
- Going back to the home for belongings when the order does not allow it
Penalties for a Violation
A violation is punishable by a fine of up to $5,000, up to two and a half years in a house of correction, or both. The court must also order a certified batterer's intervention program, unless the judge finds good cause not to and writes down the reasons. A conviction also means a criminal record, so it is critical to speak with an experienced criminal defense attorney early.
Only the Person Named in the Order Can Violate It
The order restricts the person it was issued against. The person who asked for it cannot violate it or waive it, and only a judge can change or end it. If the other person calls or comes to the door, the person under the order is still the one at risk. The other person's consent is not a defense, although it may matter at sentencing.
How High Tensions Can Run
In April 2022, outside the Cambridge District Court in Medford, a man whom Attorney Barabino had represented in his effort to extend a restraining order was accused of striking a family member with his car and shooting him. The ABA Journal reported the story, which is included here only to show how high tensions can run in these cases. A charge is only an accusation.
Man who failed to obtain restraining order against nephew is accused of shooting him outside courthouse
ABA Journal, April 8, 2022, by Debra Cassens Weiss · Reprinted with credit to the ABA Journal · PDF, 2 pages
Original article: ABA Journal, "Man who failed to obtain restraining order against nephew is accused of shooting him outside courthouse". Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Contact William Barabino at 781-393-5900
If you have been served with a restraining order, are seeking one, or have been accused of a restraining order violation, contact criminal defense attorney William Barabino by calling his Medford, Massachusetts, law office at 781-393-5900. You may also complete his online contact form.