Attorney Barabino takes pride in representing people charged with probation violations in Massachusetts. That is true whether he represented the person on the underlying case, or another attorney represented them and has asked him to step in.
If you have been given notice of a probation violation, contact the Medford, Massachusetts, law office of William Barabino at 781-393-5900 for a free and confidential consultation.
Notice of a Probation Violation
When someone on probation is alleged to have violated the court's order, the Probation Department issues a notice of violation, and the person must appear in court. That first appearance is much like an arraignment: the person is notified of the alleged violation, and the case moves forward from there.
A notice can be issued for:
- A claimed violation of a term or condition of probation
- A new alleged crime
Common alleged violations include:
- Failing to report to probation as required
- Failing to follow other conditions of probation, such as drug or alcohol restrictions
- Failing to pay court-ordered fees or restitution
- Being arrested or charged with a new offense
A person can be found in violation based on a new charge even if that criminal case later ends in a not-guilty finding.
The Detention Hearing
At that first court appearance, probation decides whether to ask that the person be held in custody until a final hearing. That detention hearing is a critical stage of the case.
The detention hearing is a critical point in a probation violation case.
What Can Be Done at This Stage
Attorney Barabino approaches this stage in three steps:
- He negotiates with probation not to seek detention.
- He argues to the judge that the person should not be detained.
- If detention is ordered, he asks for a very short date for the final hearing, so that any time in custody is brief.
Why Staying Out Matters
Staying out pending the final hearing matters for two reasons. First, it means avoiding jail now. Second, it means the person can walk into the final surrender hearing, rather than being brought before the judge in the dock, in handcuffs. In Attorney Barabino's experience, walking in can make a difference in how the court approaches the case. Being brought in from custody can make it easier for the court to impose a jail sentence.
Walking into the final hearing, rather than being brought before the judge in the dock in handcuffs, can make a difference in how the court approaches the case.
What the Court Considers
Before a person can be detained on the probation matter, the court must first find probable cause to believe a violation occurred. Even then, detention is not automatic. In deciding whether to hold the person, the court considers:
- The probationer's criminal record
- The nature of the offense for which the person is on probation
- The nature of any newly charged offense
- The nature of any other pending alleged violations
- The likelihood the person will appear at the final hearing if not held in custody
- The likelihood of incarceration if a violation is found
The Final Hearing
The final hearing, sometimes called a final surrender hearing, is a two-step process.
Step One: Whether There Was a Violation
The first step is to decide whether a violation occurred. That can happen in two ways: the person may admit or stipulate to the violation, or the judge may decide the question after a hearing. At a hearing, both sides may present evidence, and Attorney Barabino can cross-examine witnesses.
The rules are more relaxed than at a criminal trial. Hearsay may be admitted, for various reasons, though the court should rely on it only if it is substantially reliable. The judge then finds either that there was a violation, or that there was not. The Probation Department has to prove a violation by a preponderance of the evidence, a lower standard than proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
Step Two: Disposition
If the judge finds a violation, the court then decides what to do. The court can:
- Continue the person on probation, sometimes called reprobating
- Terminate probation
- Modify probation, including by adding conditions or extending the time
- Revoke probation and impose a sentence
If a sentence was suspended when the person was placed on probation, and the court revokes probation, that suspended sentence is imposed (G.L. c. 279, § 3). The judge can, instead, continue the person on probation rather than revoke it.
Continuances Without a Finding
If the underlying case was continued without a finding, a violation can lead the court to revoke the continuance and enter a guilty finding, which can have devastating consequences.
A continuance without a finding can be revoked, and a guilty finding entered, which can have devastating consequences.
How Attorney Barabino Prepares These Cases
The goal is creativity and hard work. If someone is doing well on probation, the Probation Department and the court often want to see that person succeed. Attorney Barabino has found that thorough preparation is essential. These hearings can move quickly, and the stakes are high.
Contact William Barabino at 781-393-5900
If you are facing a probation violation, contact criminal defense attorney William Barabino by calling his Medford, Massachusetts, law office at 781-393-5900. You may also complete his online contact form. Whatever your situation, we are ready to address it and to find what works best for you.