In Massachusetts, the formal charge is operating under the influence of liquor, or with a blood alcohol level of .08 or greater (G.L. c. 90, § 24). Most people call it OUI, DUI, or DWI. A person can be convicted in two ways: by proof that alcohol reduced their ability to drive safely, or by proof that their blood alcohol level was .08 or higher. A conviction can rest on either one. Not everyone takes a breath test, and this page explains what that means for a case. It focuses on alcohol. Impaired driving by drugs is covered by the same law, but it is a different kind of case.
Attorney Barabino represents people charged with OUI in Massachusetts. If you were arrested, contact the Medford, Massachusetts, law office of William Barabino at 781-393-5900 for a free and confidential consultation.
Trial or Plea: How the Decision Gets Made
Every OUI case starts the same way. Attorney Barabino studies the facts in the first interviews and police reports, and then he considers whether the case is likely to go to trial or to end in a plea. In his 23 years of criminal defense, he has found that part of his job is to guide, explain, and advise, so that you understand your options and the reasons for each before you decide.
What Goes Into the Decision
The strength of the evidence is a major factor. But many people also weigh:
- Wanting their license back
- Wanting to put the case behind them
- The potential cost of a trial, which for some is a real concern
- The cost of not being able to drive
- The risk of a conviction. A guilty verdict after trial carries consequences a negotiated resolution may avoid, for example a conviction on the record and the license loss that comes with it. A plea or a first-offense program under § 24D means a 45 to 90 day license loss. Depending on the facts, the circumstances, and the charge, jail is also a possibility that cannot be ignored, although it is highly unlikely on a first offense.
A strong case for the government is one of the things to weigh, and Attorney Barabino will talk through all of it with you.
Body Camera Video
Many police officers now wear body cameras. The video can be very telling, because it shows the stop, the officer's questions, and any roadside tests from start to finish. It can also take time to get from the government, which has slowed the decision about a plea or a trial. When the video arrives, it is often a key part of Attorney Barabino's final advice to the client.
What the Government Must Prove
To convict you of OUI on the impairment theory, the government has to prove three things beyond a reasonable doubt:
- You operated a motor vehicle.
- You did so on a public way, or another place the public can access.
- You were under the influence of intoxicating liquor at the time.
If the government charges the .08 theory instead, the third item is that your blood alcohol level was .08 or higher, as shown by a valid test.
The government must prove all three elements, and if it fails on any one of them, the verdict must be not guilty.
Operation and Public Way
Attorney Barabino has won acquittals on defenses to the first two elements, operation and public way. Those defenses are less common, because in most cases the police stop the car on a public street. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
What "Under the Influence" Means
In most cases, the real fight is over the third element. The law does not forbid drinking and then driving. The question is whether the person drank enough to reduce their mental clarity, self-control, and reflexes, and with them their ability to drive safely (Commonwealth v. Connolly, 394 Mass. 169 (1985)). The government does not have to show bad driving, but it does have to show reduced ability.
Having a drink is not the offense. The question is whether alcohol reduced the person's ability to drive safely.
Some people are simply poor drivers, and others are distracted by a phone. Driving badly is not the same as being impaired by alcohol.
The Signs Police Rely On
Officers usually point to the same signs:
- Slurred or changed speech
- Bloodshot eyes
- The smell of alcohol
- An admission to drinking
- Unsteadiness on the feet
- Slow reflexes
Attorney Barabino looks closely at each one, and at whether something else could explain it.
Roadside Tests, Breath Tests, and What a Jury Hears
Roadside Assessments (Field Sobriety Tests)
Police often ask a driver to do roadside assessments, also called field sobriety tests, such as walking a line or standing on one leg. They are not like the breath test. No Massachusetts law suspends a license for declining them, and officers do not have to tell you that you may decline. If a person declines, the jury cannot be told. Declining does not prevent an arrest, though, and if a person does the tests, the officer can describe how they went. Sometimes the way someone actually performed, especially on video, helps the defense.
The Breath Test
If you are arrested, police will ask you to take a breath test. Massachusetts law treats driving as consent to the test, but a person can still decline. The consequence is a license suspension, not a crime (see "Your License" below). A reading of .08 or higher makes a case harder, but it is not a guarantee of guilt. The result has to meet legal requirements before a jury can rely on it, and Attorney Barabino examines whether it did.
A jury never hears that a person refused a breath test or declined roadside tests.
Many people assume the jury would hear it, and that it would count against them. In Massachusetts, a refusal cannot be used as evidence at trial (G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(e); Opinion of the Justices, 412 Mass. 1201 (1992); Commonwealth v. McGrail, 419 Mass. 774 (1995)). One caution: if a person agrees to the breath test and then does not complete it properly, that can be treated differently from a plain refusal.
Prior Offenses the Jury Does Not Hear
If you are charged with a second, third, fourth, or fifth offense, the jury in the first trial is not told about your prior record. If you are found guilty, a separate proceeding follows, before the same jury or a new one, to decide whether the prior offenses are proven (G.L. c. 278, § 11A). The government often has records to offer, but Attorney Barabino still tests the proof. That protection has limits: if a person testifies, a prior conviction can sometimes be used to question their credibility.
Your License
License suspensions are confusing, because more than one rule can apply to the same arrest. The exact numbers depend on your age, your record, and how the case ends, so Attorney Barabino goes through yours with you. The points below describe adult drivers, 21 and older.
If a Breath Test Shows .08 or Higher
The license is suspended until the case is decided, and never for more than 30 days (G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(f)(2) and § 24N). If the case ends sooner, the suspension ends then. Someone who was not arrested at the scene, for example someone who later receives a summons, generally is not facing it.
If You Refuse the Breath Test
For an adult with no prior OUI, a first-time refusal generally means a 180-day license suspension. It is longer for anyone under 21 and for anyone with a prior offense, and a prior can mean years, so the exact figures depend on age and record. By comparison, a person who takes the test and registers .08 or higher typically faces a 30-day suspension, which lasts until the case is resolved if that happens sooner. The police take the license on the spot. If the case ends in a not-guilty finding or a dismissal, the license is not restored automatically. The person has to ask the court for a hearing, where the law presumes the license should be restored unless the government shows that doing so would likely endanger the public (G.L. c. 90, § 24(1)(f)(1)).
First-Offense Programs and Hardship Licenses
Some first offenders qualify for a program under G.L. c. 90, § 24D. The person consents to up to two years of probation and an alcohol education program, and the license loss is 45 to 90 days. This may be available whether a case is resolved by a plea or after a trial, but it does not apply to everyone. A person may also be able to ask for a limited hardship license, which is not guaranteed.
What the Jury Will Not Hear
In a Massachusetts OUI trial, the jury does not hear about:
- Prior OUI offenses
- A refusal to take the breath test
- A decision to decline field sobriety tests (roadside assessments)
The sections above explain each of these and their limits. Attorney Barabino can explain how they apply to your case.
How Attorney Barabino Prepares an OUI Defense
Trial Preparation
Thorough preparation is the key to his work. Attorney Barabino investigates all of the facts and law that may affect your case. That can include your medical history and any condition that could have affected your roadside test results, such as a problem with balance or coordination. He also speaks with third-party witnesses to the stop and the arrest. The same preparation applies to more serious charges, including second and later offenses and drug-impaired driving.
Training in OUI Defense
Attorney Barabino is a member of the National College of OUI Defense, which helps him stay current on the hardest questions in OUI law. In 2013 and again in 2017 he completed an intensive three-day seminar at Harvard University devoted only to the defense of people accused of OUI.
Contact William Barabino at 781-393-5900
If you are facing an OUI charge, contact criminal defense attorney William Barabino by calling his Medford, Massachusetts, law office at 781-393-5900. You may also complete his online contact form. Whatever your situation, we are ready to address it and to find what works best for you.