License or Authority in Massachusetts Criminal Cases (G.L. c. 278, § 7)

License or Authority in M…

A criminal charge sometimes turns on whether you had a license, a prescription, or some other legal authority to do the thing you’re accused of doing. Massachusetts has a specific rule about that issue: who has to raise it, and who has to prove it.

At a Glance: License or Authority
Burden stays with the Commonwealth
it must prove you did not have the license, once the issue is in the case
A production burden
in some cases you have to come forward with evidence first
Firearms are different
after 2023, lack of a license is an element the Commonwealth must prove
Written notice
required before trial if you intend to rely on a license defense
The law: G.L. c. 278, § 7; District Court Instruction 3.160; Mass. R. Crim. P. 14.3(b)

I’ll take it in this order: what “license or authority” means, when the court will consider it, who has the burden of proof, when a defendant has to come forward with evidence, how firearms cases are different, the advance-notice rule, and what happens if no evidence of a license is offered.

What “License or Authority” Means

In many cases, the conduct charged would be lawful if the person had a license, an appointment, or some other authority to do it. A common example is someone charged in connection with a controlled substance who had a valid prescription. Another is a professional who was licensed to do the work at issue.

The statute is G.L. c. 278, § 7. It says: “A defendant in a criminal prosecution, relying for his justification upon a license, appointment, admission to practice as an attorney at law, or authority, shall prove the same; and, until so proved, the presumption shall be that he is not so authorized.”

That sentence is easy to misread. It does not mean the defendant has to prove the defense beyond a reasonable doubt. It addresses who has to come forward with evidence of a license or authority in the first place. Once that evidence is in, the Commonwealth still has to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the license, appointment, or authority was not there.

Coming forward with some evidence of a license is not the same as proving you had one. Once that evidence is in, the Commonwealth still has to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that you did not have the license, appointment, or authority.

When the Court Will Consider License or Authority

The question of license or authority is in the case when evidence has been presented that the defendant may have had legal authority to do what he or she is charged with doing because he or she:

  • Held a license to do a certain action;
  • Came within an exception to the statute that permits a certain action; or
  • Has some other claim of appointment or authority to do a certain action.

Those are the circumstances the model jury instruction walks through. If no such evidence is offered, and the license is an exception rather than an element of the crime, the jury is told not to consider license or authority at all. More on that below.

Who Has the Burden of Proving There Was No License or Authority

The burden of proof stays with the Commonwealth. It must prove every element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. And when license or authority is properly in the case, it must also prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not:

  • Hold a license to do a certain action;
  • Come within an exception to the statute that permits a certain action; or
  • Have some other claim of appointment or authority to do a certain action.

If the Commonwealth has proved all of the elements of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt, and has also proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not have that license, exception, or authority, then the jury may find the defendant guilty.

If the Commonwealth has failed to prove any element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt, or has failed to prove that the defendant did not have the license, exception, or authority, then the jury must find the defendant not guilty.

When the Defendant Has to Come Forward With Evidence

There are cases in which the absence of a license is not itself an element of the crime. That happens when the prohibition is general, and the license is an exception to it. In those cases, there is no jury issue on license, appointment, or authority unless the defendant introduces some evidence of it. That is a burden of production — coming forward with evidence — not a burden of proof.

Once the defendant has introduced that evidence, the burden is on the Commonwealth to prove the absence of the license, appointment, or authority beyond a reasonable doubt.

Examples of charges where this exceptional-license framework has been applied include:

  • Admission to practice as an attorney at law;
  • A physician’s authority to prescribe a controlled substance;
  • A license to practice medicine; and
  • A license to sell liquor.

Examples of circumstances that are not treated that way include:

In those situations, the missing insurance or authority is part of what the Commonwealth has to prove as an element, not an exception the defendant has to raise.

A license to carry a firearm used to be listed with the exceptional licenses above. That is no longer the law. The next section explains why.

Firearms Licensure After 2023

In Commonwealth v. Guardado, 491 Mass. 666 (2023), the Supreme Judicial Court held that the absence of a valid firearms license is an essential element of unlawful possession of a firearm under G.L. c. 269, § 10(a). The Commonwealth must prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant did not have a valid firearms license. G.L. c. 278, § 7 no longer applies to that charge.

That matters both at the time of an arrest and at trial. An officer may arrest someone for carrying or possessing a firearm without being able to confirm a license on the spot. But at a trial on a § 10(a) charge, lack of a valid license is something the Commonwealth has to prove. It is not an affirmative defense the defendant has to raise.

In a firearms case under G.L. c. 269, § 10(a), the absence of a valid license is an element of the crime. The Commonwealth must prove it. G.L. c. 278, § 7 no longer applies to that charge.

The related posts linked below cover the carrying and possession charges themselves.

Advance Notice

A defendant who intends to rely on a defense based on a license, a claim of authority or ownership, or an exemption has to give written notice. Under Mass. R. Crim. P. 14.3(b), the defendant must notify the prosecutor in writing, and file a copy with the clerk, within the time provided for pretrial motions, or later if the judge directs. If that notice is not given, the defense may not be relied on, though the judge may allow a late filing for cause.

That is a notice rule. It is not a change in who has the burden of proof.

If There Is No Evidence of a License or Authority

If no evidence is presented suggesting the defendant may have had legal authority to do what he or she is charged with doing — because he or she held a license, came within a statutory exception, or has some other claim of appointment or authority — then, in a case where license or authority is an exception rather than an element, the jury must not consider the question of license or authority.

Firearms cases under § 10(a) are different, as explained above: the Commonwealth still has to prove the absence of a valid license, even if the defendant offers no license evidence.

Related Charges

  • Carrying a firearm (G.L. c. 269, § 10(a)): after 2023, the Commonwealth must prove the absence of a valid license as an element of the charge.
  • Possession of a firearm (G.L. c. 269, § 10(h)): a related firearms charge; the license-or-authority issues are close, but not identical, to the § 10(a) rule discussed above.
  • Use of a motor vehicle without authority (G.L. c. 90, § 24(2)(a)): lack of authority is part of what the Commonwealth has to prove, not an exception the defendant has to raise.
  • Criminal intent: how knowledge, intent, and related mental states are proved.
  • Proof beyond a reasonable doubt: the standard that stays on the Commonwealth, including on the absence of a license once that issue is in the case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to prove that I had a license?

No. In some cases you have to come forward with some evidence of a license, when the license is an exception and not an element of the crime. Once that evidence is in, the Commonwealth has to prove you did not have it, beyond a reasonable doubt. In a firearms case under G.L. c. 269, § 10(a), you do not have to raise it; the Commonwealth has to prove the absence of a valid license as an element.

What if I had a license but I do not have the physical license with me in court?

In a case where the license is an exception, some evidence of the license or authority has to be presented before the jury will be asked to consider it. That evidence is not limited to handing the physical license to the judge, but if no evidence of a license is offered at all, the jury is told not to consider the issue. In a § 10(a) firearms case, the Commonwealth still has to prove the absence of a valid license, whether or not you offer a license.

Does this apply to a prescription for a controlled substance?

A physician’s authority to prescribe, and a claim that a prescription was validly issued, are among the usual license-or-authority examples. Whether a particular prescription is a defense depends on the charge and the facts.

I was arrested with a gun. Is it my job to show the license at trial?

Not on a charge under G.L. c. 269, § 10(a). After Guardado, the Commonwealth must prove you did not have a valid license.

Facing a License or Authority Issue? Talk to a Lawyer

Whether a license or authority issue is an element, an exception, or something that has to be raised in advance can change the shape of the case. You don’t have to sort that out alone. The Law Office of William J. Barabino in Medford represents clients throughout Greater Boston.

Call 781-393-5900 to talk about your charge and your options.

Related Articles

Disclaimer

This article is for general educational information about Massachusetts criminal law. It is not legal advice for your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change. For advice about a specific case, speak with a licensed Massachusetts attorney.